Validity of one-day physical activity recall for estimating total energy expenditure in elderly residents at long-term care facilities: Clinical evaluation of energy requirements study (CLEVER study)

Malnutrition is a severe problem among elderly residents living in long-term care facilities. A simple and accurate estimation for total daily energy expenditure (TEE) is required in order to provide them with an adequate amount of food. The purpose of this study was to validate a physical activity assessment tool for estimating TEE among elderly residents. The data of 58 subjects aged 69-99 y were analyzed in this study. The one-day physical activity recall was filled out by facility staff for a typical day. TEE was measured by the doubly labeled water (DLW) method (TEE_DLW), and predicted by one-day physical activity recall using the basal metabolic rate (pTEE_BMR) and body weight (pTEE_BW). The TEE_DLW, pTEE_BMR and pTEE_BW were 1,129±196 kcal/d, 1,186±251 kcal/d and 1,326±236 kcal/d, respectively. In a regression model, body weight, movement means and sex explained 39.0% of the variance in the difference between pTEE_BMR and TEE_DLW (p<0.05). Percentage of fat mass, body weight, and Barthel Index except mobility explained 47.3% of the variance in the difference between pTEE_BW and TEE_DLW (p<0.05). The current results suggested that pTEE_BW is not recommended to estimate TEE because the error depends on body size, and pTEE_BMR was significantly correlated with TEE_DLW but also included systematic errors in elderly residents. In order to improve the accuracy of the present assessment to estimate TEE, it is necessary to establish a new equation of basal metabolic rate for elderly residents and consider sex and movement means to estimate TEE.